In this season finale, we look back at every mystery from Season 2: the Perron family haunting, the Enfield Poltergeist, Annabelle, Loftus Hall, Amityville, Madison Seminary, the Smurl family, Hinsdale House, La Llorona, the Paris Catacombs, the Warrens, and more.
Think of it as our haunted awards show: best haunting, worst story, most believable case, biggest scam energy, creepiest location, and plenty of other spooky little categories from the ghost-filled mess we just survived.
So grab your flashlight, check the corners of the room, and join us for one last walk through A Haunting before Mystery Date moves into whatever strange world comes next.
💌 Got a mystery or spooky story to share? We want to hear from you!
Send your tales, tips, or local legends to us at mysterydatepodcast@gmail.com or call the mystery hotline at (216) 770-4881. You just might hear your story on a future episode!
Follow Us for Updates & Behind-the-Scenes Chaos:
Website: https://www.mysterydatepodcast.com
Instagram: /mysterydatepodcast
TikTok: /mysterydatepodcast
Shop: www.mysteryandco.com
Sources & Further Reading: Curious minds welcome!
For a full list of sources, extras, and reading recommendations related to this episode, check out the episode blog on our website.
Production:
Mystery Date is written, edited, filmed, and produced by Christian Sullivan and Kate Sullivan. Music and sound are provided by Descript stock media and Artlist Media. We do not own the rights to any of the images shared in our episodes. All images in this video were sourced from Wiki Commons.
Timestamps:
00:00 Season 2 Finale Setup
01:08 Meet the Hosts
02:45 Season Thanks and Whats Next
04:33 Debrief Rules and Spoilers
05:07 Ghost Lore Recap
06:28 Conjuring Farmhouse Case
07:17 Enfield Poltergeist Debate
08:13 Annabelle Hard No
08:52 Loftus Hall Folklore
10:02 Ghost Hunting Gear
10:47 Amityville Murders
11:21 Amityville Haunting Claims
12:17 Madison Seminary Investigation
14:05 Smurl Family Haunting
16:25 Two Lies and Legend Game
18:58 Hinsdale House Residuals
20:11 Demon Lore Shift
21:02 Devil Made Me Do It Trial
22:25 Queen Mary Ghost Ship
23:17 Winchester Mystery House
24:38 Borley Rectory Verdicts
25:56 La Llorona Explained
26:36 Paris Catacombs Full Send
27:48 Warrens Mixed Legacy
29:39 Awards Show Begins
29:55 Best Haunting Pick
31:09 Scariest Story Winner
32:22 Best Location Debate
34:01 Believable vs Not
35:51 Most Tragic Case
38:44 Top Episodes For Newbies
40:52 Best Episode Overall
44:34 Season Two Takeaways
46:10 Do You Believe Now
47:52 Late Night Goals
48:41 Season Three Plans
49:43 Thanks And Where To Find Us
51:56 Break And Farewell