In this episode, we break down the Lutz family’s timeline of events, the blessing of the house, their sudden flight after less than a month, and the investigation led by Ed and Lorraine Warren. We also examine the famous photograph, the séance inside the home, and the skepticism that followed. Was Amityville truly haunted, or did fear, media, and opportunity collide to create one of the most debated paranormal cases in history?
💌 Got a mystery or spooky story to share? We want to hear from you!
Send your tales, tips, or local legends to us at mysterydatepodcast@gmail.com
or head to mysterydatepodcast.com to leave us a voice message. You just might hear your story on a future episode!
Follow Us for Updates & Behind-the-Scenes Chaos:
Website: https://www.mysterydatepodcast.com
Instagram: /mysterydatepodcast
TikTok: /mysterydatepodcast
Shop: www.mysteryandco.com
Sources & Further Reading: Curious minds welcome!
For a full list of sources, extras, and reading recommendations related to this episode, check out the episode blog on our website.
Production.
Mystery Date is written, edited, filmed, and produced by Christian Sullivan and Kate Sullivan. Music and sound are provided by Descript stock media and Artlist Media. We do not own the rights to any of the images shared in our episodes. All images in this video were sourced from Wiki Commons.
Timestamps:
00:00 Amityville Returns
01:49 Date Night Setup
04:03 Buying The Murder House
06:52 The Priest Warning
08:46 Family Changes And Jodi
13:40 3 15 AM Begins
17:04 Escalation And Black Slime
24:36 We Ran From The House
27:06 Warrens Enter Amityville
31:00 The Ghost Boy Photo
31:56 Ghost Boy Photo Debate
33:53 Who Could Have Faked It
35:28 Dangerously Haunted Claims
38:16 Seance Doubts Emerge
41:02 Book Deal Hoax Allegations
44:45 Evidence Problems and Slime
46:28 Later Owners and Psychology
49:14 Why Amityville Endures
50:46 Was It Really Haunted
51:41 Final Take Mixed Truth
57:47 Date Night Debrief Bands
01:00:52 Life Updates and Wrap Up
01:01:50 Closing Thanks and Call In